Dear Ritter,

I agree with your comment on Young's statement. Creative writing is definitely not just for English classes, and it can surely be an academic tool. I think creative writing is an excellent way of introducing and engaging students into their writing. It is also a very useful way of practicing one's writing. You were right on in saying that student's should be using their creative minds in any time of writing assignments including formal assignments. So I wonder why this separation exist? Why do some people think creative writing and formal writing are very distinctive forms of writing that can not overlap? How can we show our students that both forms work hand in hand?

I really enjoyed the idea of : Without writing there is no history, philosophy etc., therefore, WAC has always existed. If we look at it in that general point of view, I agree with Rose as well; however, I think the recent goals of WAC are more specific and detailed. WAC can no longer be satisfied with this general definition and view. There is so much more to WAC and we must embrace all that it has to offer, in every classroom.

Your experience with the professor, clearly shows how every educator seems to have their own definition of what "good" writing should be. As future educators, we should not limit ourselves and our students by doing this. There is no one way or one right way to write. If the writing is legible, and proves a point (like you said), the rest is just technical and that's what the editing process is for. We don't have to stress ourselves out and our students with the technicalities of writing, because that's exactly why many students find themselves distant and incapable toward writing. I can't believe some educators are negative about writing. They are the ones that ruin it for the rest of us. I'm sorry that you had to experience a teacher who feels that way about writing, and I mostly feel sorry for the teacher. I hope the experience allows you to learn and grow as a person and a writer. It's good to see the teacher didn't completely discourage you.

- Crystal Rios